A-City's only designated fake news

A-City Thunder Weekly

Campus

General studies teaching materials revealed to use pictures from 25 years ago

The Victoria Harbour in textbooks still has the pre-reclamation coastline.

General studies teaching materials revealed to use pictures from 25 years ago

STAFF REPORT | A parent, opening the new edition of the General Studies textbook for this school year, found that a photo captioned "Panorama of Victoria Harbour" did not match the current coastline. In the photo, the Kwun Tong area still consists of factory buildings, although reclamation works in that district were completed as early as 2001.

The parent posted a comparison image on social media, pointing out that the caption for the photo on page 23 says "taken in 2025". This newspaper asked the publisher, which admitted that the photo was taken from a stock photo library and that "the year label is incorrect".

The publisher said it had notified all schools in Hong Kong and would correct the error in the next edition. This newspaper checked the other images in the same textbook and found two other street-scene photos in which the bus models had already been retired in 2018.

A teacher who has taught General Studies for ten years said outdated textbook images are nothing new. "The problem is that it is not just one." She said that last year a question in the subject asked for "Hong Kong's newest railway branch line", and the answer was the one that opened ten years earlier.

The Education Bureau replied to this newspaper that when textbooks are submitted for review, content accuracy is checked, and that "the year of the images is the publisher's responsibility". Of the 32 General Studies textbooks submitted for review this year, five were required to be revised because of "outdated information".

A reporter from this newspaper saw at a bookstore in Mong Kok that this edition of the textbook was still on the shelf for sale, priced at HK$128.

Related

Letters

No letters yet.

Sign in to write a letter.